Save Lake Malawi (and the chambo!)

The involvement of well-known fraudster Wavisanga Silungwe[1] in the activism against the oil exploration in Lake Malawi should not deter us from the real danger of this exploration.black2

Oil is the commodity that has caused the most resource curse of all. In fact, in all African countries with oil exploitation it has negatively impacted on the quality of life. Most famously in Nigeria, where the whole Niger Delta is polluted with oil, and the profits are diverted to the top politicians in Abuja. The Niger Delta has its freedom fighters, or terrorists (depending on whose definition you follow) of MEND, who are in continuous battle with government forces (who are indistinguishable from organized crime, according to the famous photojournalist Ed Kashi) making life in the Niger Delta a living hell. (Incidentally, the prominent activist Ken Saro-Wiwa was murdered by the Nigerian justice system for standing up for the rights of the people in the Niger Delta).

In Angola, Chad, South Sudan and other oil exporting countries the bigger picture is the same: untold riches for a small minority, and misery for the large section of the population. Oil and other mineral resources are a gold mine (excuse the pun) for rent seeking corruptionists. Only in countries with exceptionally good governance like Norway, has oil contributed to the quality of life for the population.

In Africa there is only one country where mineral resources have improved living conditions: Botswana, which is famous worldwide for its good governance. In all other African countries, mineral resources have caused misery.

On top of that, oil exploration under water is infamous for causing large scale pollution. Even in the USA, which has many times better implementation of its safety and environmental regulations than Malawi, the Deep Water Horizon has caused immeasurable damage through a colossal oil spill. The same goes for the Exxon Valdez. Both disasters caused massive death among the fish, and gigantic losses of livelihood in fishing communities.

Oil is depleted in a few years or decades at the most, while fish, being a renewable resource, will be there forever. Fish breed, oil does not.  if we explore the oil we have resources only for a short time, while we kill the fish that can be there forever if we refrain from pumping oil.

In Malawi, with much laxer enforcement of regulations, we know the pollution will happen, like it does with horrible regularity in Nigeria.

In Malawi we have a precedent for large scale exploration of mineral resources: the Karonga uranium mine of Palladin (the Australian company that is banned from uranium mining in its home country because of its environmental pollution record). What has the population benefitted from this mine? The promised job opportunities  have never materialized, the business opportunities just the same, and some unexplained earth quakes have been blamed on the mine even though government has failed to investigate properly. A tax holiday for Palladin has made sure that the Malawian tax payer has not benefited from our own uranium resources. So in short: nothing.

Until Malawi’s governance has improved to standards comparable with the Norwegians, we cannot expect to benefit from oil exploration in Lake Malawi, but we can expect large scale misery and pollution.


N O !

[1] Wavisanga Silungwe is best known for running the fraudulent “Karonga Polytechnic”, which advertises as a distance education school, but is in fact a non-existent entity. It collects study fees from unsuspecting would-be students and then fails to deliver. Its recognition from the famous UNISA was withdrawn years ago, but Silungwe keeps advertising with it. Silungwe is also known for fraudulently claiming to represent the Karonga business community, while the legitimate business community in Karonga will have nothing to do with him because of his fraudulent activities and overdrawn imaginative claims about himself.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s